Saturday, February 22, 2014

"My bias is a true artist, like, OMG": music production and songwriting credits explained

It's hard to think up any music fandom with an insecurity complex bigger than any given k-pop fandom.  People who are into k-pop (regardless of which group is their fave) can't just seem to say "I like this bubblegum shit, because it sounds good to me, and that's that, and if you don't like it fuck you" - they have to constantly justify everything both to themselves and others, so they can confirm that "yes it's socially acceptable for me to like this group".  That's the real motivation behind a lot of the excessive caring about vocal technique ("See?  My favourite group are talented, see? SEE?") chart success ("Look, everyone likes them in Korea, they MUST be good!") and awards ("They won something!  They're so special!") that many fans engage in.  It's also why fans' eyes light up with delight like twinkly little snowglobes whenever they are alerted to the rare eventuality of a cog in their favourite sculpted corporate pop music delivery machine getting a songwriting credit somewhere, and also why they then go and trot out these song credits tirelessly on forums and websites in some pathetic cyber-dick-measuring contest.

I thought it would be useful to demystify the meaning of technical terms in album credits, as well as how these terms are allocated to different people and also what it means when people co-write, so when the next media hype article comes along about artist X co-arranging song Y with producer Z, you don't get the wrong idea about what's really going on and you at least have some idea about what you're stroking your e-peen about.  Because I love you guys.


Let's get started with some basic terminology:

Composer - (or "composed by") - writes the music.  If a separate lyricist, writer or arranger is not specified, the composer did these things too.

Songwriter - (or "written by") - same thing as the composer.

Lyricist (or "lyrics by", "words by") - writes the words.  Unless the lyricist is also the composer or the co-composer, the lyricist did not decide how those lyrics are sung (or rapped, or screamed, or whatever), only what the words are.  Essentially, a lyricist who only writes lyrics is the same thing as a poet (although don't ever tell a poet that - those guys are even more insecure than the average k-pop fan and will froth at the mouth and scream obscenities at you until you take it back and promise never to speak of such vile heresy again).

Arranger (or "arranged by") - the person who decides what parts go where ("we'll do the verse melody twice before going into the chorus" etc) and/or which singers and instruments do what parts ("let's have the guitar do the melody with the synth in section C, and then in section D the vocals will pick it up and we'll increase the bass"etc).

Recording engineer (or "recorded by", "tracked by") - the person who works the big desk in the studio, (hopefully) knows what all the knobs do, and records the performers.  Performers used to be recorded onto large reel-to-reel tapes, these days it's all done with computers.

Mixing engineer (or "mixed by") - the person who works the big desk in the studio, (hopefully) knows what all the knobs do, and gets the recordings from the recording engineer and adjust levels so the loudness and softness of each instrument is just right, adds effects and special stuff (I'll go into the special stuff in another blog, later) so it sounds "nice", then "mixes down" the result into a standard 2-track (stereo) file.  Except on very big high-budget projects, the recording and mixing engineer are typically the same person - if a separate mixing engineer is not specified, the recording engineer did this job.

Engineer for Girl's Day song "Don't Forget Me"
(The above image and caption was added by 아저씨 as an example of "co-authorship" (see below) - however he gets no royalty percentage from this blog's hefty income draw of $0.00 because I really liked the engineering on "Don't Forget Me" and actually think it's one of the most well-produced songs in k-pop so I'm going to withhold his name from the royalty split for this reason, yes record labels can be this petty)

Audio engineer (or "engineered by") - another word for someone who is both the recording and the mixing engineer.  An audio engineer is also what you call a person who mixes a live band, but we're talking about studio album credits here so we'll ignore this bit.

Producer (or "produced by", "production by") - the person who decides the sonic result of the mix - how much bass and treble, how thick or thin instruments sound, how loud and soft everything is, what effects would go best where, etc.  If this seems like there's a bit of crossover between "producer" and "mixing engineer"... not quite.  If it's confusing think of it like this - the producer sits back in his lounge chair smoking a cigar and saying "hmmmmm... needs more bass", and the audio engineer says "yes boss, anything you say, boss!" and twiddles the knobs on the desk to make it happen.  Sometimes the producer and the audio engineer are the same person, sometimes they are separate and sometimes the producer has no knowledge of how to use the equipment or the technical side of mixing at all, but just has a good ear!  Some very hands-on producers will also re-arrange the songs so they are also arrangers.  In k-pop, it's common for the "producer" to actually be the composer/lyricist, arranger, producer and audio engineer, all in one.  Most of the more well-known hitmaker style producers in k-pop (Brave Brothers, Shinsadong Tiger, JYP, Sweetune, etc) fit this category.

Executive producer - fronts up money for the project, effectively a sponsor.  This person is usually not involved in any other way.  An example of an executive producer who also gets involved in actual production and other areas would be JYP, but he's a rare exception.


Mastering engineer (or "mastered by") - this person gets the final 2-track mix and tweaks/optimises it in subtle ways (that I won't go into here because it would take too long) for maximum fidelity/impact on radio or in downloaded formats.  Think about the mastering engineer as equivalent to someone who gives a brand new car a buff, shine and polish once it leaves the assembly line, before it goes to sit in some car yard somewhere, so you're more likely to buy the thing.  The mastering engineer is almost always a separate person to everybody else, and sometimes they go uncredited.   Only very very cheap productions, and/or productions in extremely non-commercial genres with absolutely zero aspirations to mass popularity would release a recording without mastering it first.

There are other terms, but these are the main ones you'll come across... but let's not forget:

Performer - plays/sings the music.  May or may not have had fuck-all to do with any of the above.  In the case of k-pop, generally not.


There are however, exceptions - exceptions that the average k-pop fan will treasure like a jewel-encrusted dildo encoded with their bias' DNA.  Let's look at some exceptional situations and how they are likely to apply to k-pop.

Co-writing - apparently CL helped compose three songs for the new 2NE1 album when she was bored.  No shit she was bored, the fucking thing was meant to come out two motherfuckin' years ago, she was probably trying to hurry the process along a bit because nobody else over at YG gave a shit.  But what does "helped compose" actually mean?  Well, according to the article:
The leader of 2NE1 composed the lyrics and co-wrote the music for the songs "If I Were You," "Baby I Miss You" and the title track off of "Crush." She also co-wrote the lyrics for the song "MTBD" with YG producer-in-residence Teddy.
If she's the only one who composed those lyrics for those three songs, then she's the sole writer of the words which means we're probably going to get filler-standard lyrics like the Korean equivalent of "alone" rhymed with "phone" and "Saturday night" rhymed with "feelin' alright".  But what about "co-wrote lyrics" and "co-wrote music", what does that really mean?  Well, maybe CL sat down with Teddy in the studio and had a chat like this:

CL: *strides into the studio in a means-business kind of way* "You know, since I'm a strong independent woman and a role model for women globally, I think I should help you write the song, because I think a female presence is important to preserve the artistic and creative integrity of what 2NE1 is doing."

Teddy: "Okay then, what do you want?"

CL:  "well, in that bit in our new song where it goes "eh eh eh eh", can we make the first "eh" a bit lower than the other ones?  I think that this female creative input that I'm giving now will show the world that 2NE1 are strong independent women."

Teddy:  "Rightio... anything else?"

CL: "Nope!... Oh, WAIT!  In that MDTB song, I want to say "2NE1, bitches!" at some point... like, really LOUD.  Because we're got to show the world how we're redefining the pop music scene in Korea for women and I think that will send a positive message that we're not afraid to light it up and let it burn like we don't care!"

Teddy:  "... okay, is that it?"

CL: "Yep!  Can we do it?"

Teddy:  "Sure."

CL:  "Great!  Let 'em know how it feels damn good to be bad!" *walks out holding her head high triumphantly in the knowledge that she has taken a positive stand for creative women everywhere*

Teddy:  *sigh*...

Believe it or not, the above hypothetical scenario (assuming Teddy came through on his end of the deal and let her do that, I guess we'll find out soon eventually) would be enough for CL to get one co-writing vocal credit and one co-writing musical credit on an album sleeve.  Of course, perhaps she's actually done a whole lot more than that, but my point is that to get her name on the album credits, she doesn't need to do much at all.


Co-arranging is another equally curly piece of terminology - remember when Eunjung "participated in the arrangement" of "I Know The Feeling"?  As we're covered, "arranging" just means "deciding what goes where".  She didn't actually play anything, or even decide what notes get played, she just helped put the already-existing musical jigsaw pieces together.  She might have gone up to composer Baek Deoksang while he was busy recording and had a conversation like this:

Eunjung *bounces into the studio happily* "I'd like to help arrange this song!"

Deoksang "Okay then, what's on your mind?"

Eunjung "Can we have an acoustic guitar intro instead of a keys intro?  That'd be just swell!"

Deoksang "Sure."

Eunjung "Also, can Boram and Hyomin get the rap parts instead of me?  I hate getting saddled with the fucking rap parts all the time now that Hwabum isn't around to polish her nails in time to the beat."

Deoksang "Why not, Boram's always whining about how she doesn't get rap parts anyway, if I throw her a bone it'll shut her up for once."

Eunjung "Great, thanks!"  *skips off merrily*

Deoksang "Oh fuck... now I've got to give her co-arranging credit... oh well, if I tell CCM HQ there's probably a media play article in this..."

Of course, it could have been a lot more involved than that.  The point is, you don't really know - nobody does except the people involved.  Just like with co-writing, the most minimal of changes is enough to qualify as "co-arranging".


Now here's the best bit: we're assuming in these cases that songwriters are accurately reporting their songwriting splitsNobody says that they have to do that.

When composed works are reported with royalty collection agencies, each person who was involved in writing the work is apportioned a percentage of the royalties.  In the case of one person writing everything, they get 100%.  In the case of one person writing the words and another writing the music, they each get 50%.  In the case of two people writing the music it's not split 25% each by default, for the reasons outlined in the above hypotheticals - maybe one person had very minimal input.  It's instead up to the composers to work it out between themselves how to split the royalties, they've just got to agree on whatever the split is and both sign on it (and until they do, nobody gets anything).

When signing to a major label, songwriting royalties form part of the contract agreement, so you actually have to hash this stuff out with the label themselves (or in the case of k-pop, they offer you a deal and you take it, or you don't take it and another trainee takes it instead and you don't get to have a music career at all).  So when CL suddenly decides "right, I'm going to help write a song" that 5% or 25% of whatever part is apportioned to her is already spoken for, because the royalty split sheets are submitted by the label, who will usually collect royalty on behalf of the artist.  Gosh, where could this potentially go wrong?

Well, if the label has control over royalty collection they can do all sorts of fun stuff including but certainly not limited to:
  • Make songwriting royalties automatically go toward paying of production debts instead of going into the artist's pocket
  • Allow performers to purchase songwriting credit by paying a fee for inclusion on the royalty split (so they only make a profit if the song does well enough to recoup the fee), or allowing them to be part of the royalty split for free if they sacrifice something else (like a weekly wage)
  • Decide to not credit the songwriters at all by having a clause in the contract that states that any creative work made while under contract is legal property of the label
...and that's just scratching the surface, these aren't the only possibilities, just a few fairly typical ones.  Yes, success stories and people making bucketloads of money off big hits does exist, but for every G-Dragon who makes a packet off royalties there's a bunch of people like [name deleted for legal reasons] who probably put in the same amount of creative energy and got utterly shafted.


This post is just a little something to think about the next time you hear about your bias co-writing a song, before you go spazzing like a headless chicken about how awesome everything is for them and how they're so creative and genius.  You're welcome.


  1. It's surprising how a song like "IGAB" can still go through that many layers without having someone to stop and kill the people that passed that to them.

    So you're saying that there is a big chance an original song by a composer is utterly changed by the engineers? I can imagine how that would suck when they make the song terrible because of it.

    Also, SSD tiger and Cho Young Soo are composers yes?

    1. Oh and I take that gif as a shoutout to me :p

    2. By the time it goes through all the steps, a song can change drastically, yes. Compare the leaked "Wolf" to the final version, that's just the difference mixing and arrangement does.

      And yes to them being composers.

    3. not sure if true or just got trolled to listen to wolf twice

  2. "That's the real motivation behind a lot of the excessive caring about vocal technique"

    Which is why the vocals thread is such a hit.

    1. You got 'em wrapped around your little finger!

  3. I have saved this page, so from now on when a fucking YG stan tries to prove the superiority of their "artist" trough the argument "they compose their music 1!1!1!11!!!!!!! They are better than your oppa/unnie" It will save some of my fucking time and neurons...

  4. Clearly SM needs to replace their entire team. Obviously whoever did the music and lyrics for songs like Wolf or Ooof, Growl, I Got Multiple Personality Disorder and Everybody should be fired for those songs. The ones that worked on f(x)'s Pink Tape album should be kept and used for other singers, unless it happens to be the same team, then clearly there's something wrong with them. Anyway, whenever we see reports on some idol revealed to have been involved in composing a song and writing the lyrics, their fans probably thought that they did everything by themselves. It could be as simple as adding an "Ah" or "Grr" in the song, but of course, the insecure fangirls need to delude themselves this way to prove to themselves that their idols have talent. I'd comment things like: 'That's why the song sucked because this idol had some part in creating the song" just to piss off the fangirls. It's hilarious to see how insecure they can be.

    1. The reason why most idols don't get to write songs is because they'd be no fucking good at it. Why would a company take that kind of risk. It's one of the things the idol system doesn't teach.

    2. I didn't even know that there's an idol system. I agree, most songs "written" and "composed' by idols suck. Anyway, are you going to be writing a story on being a trainee in a company like SM or YG and the idol system? That would be fun to read.

    3. Dsign Music:

      2013: f(x) - "Rum Pum Pum Pum" and "Airplane" from the album Pink Tape released by SM Entertainment
      2013: EXO - "Wolf" single from the album XOXO released by SM Entertainment
      2013: Girls' Generation - "I Got a Boy" single from the album I Got a Boy released by SM Entertainment

      As kpopalypse oppar said tho there's a lot going on behind the stages so you'll never know who and how much involvement they had in a song. Maybe Lee Soo Man micromanaged the IGAB composing/recording/arranging stages on the other hand since he doesn't care about f(x) it's probable he only listened to Pink Tape after it came out, who knows what happened.

      In my case when I look for new music I look for artists AND composers/producers I like.

  5. If there's only one name under "composer/lyricist" can we safely assume that s/he did all the composing, or can complete writing credits also be somehow bought?

    1. The rights to songs can be completely bought, however the original songwriters will still be listed. For instance, Michael Jackson bought the rights to all the Beatles' songs, but if you buy a Beatles songbook it still says "Lennon/McCartney" under the songwriting credit.

      Further reading:

  6. That gif is why I don't like pissing in urinals unless it has those little walls/dividers in between each urinal.

    1. I've got to admit I just use the cubicle if there's someone at the urinal already.

  7. I co-wrote and co-arranged this post by adding an image/caption for engineers.

    1. The royalty split for this blog has already been submitted. You'll have to take this one to court.

  8. Just one question: I wonder how Idols manage to make music on TV shows - for eg. G- Dragon with Hyungdon and Junho from 2pm made some okay ballad on another one. Also, what happens to the creative royalties on them?

    1. They get paid a flat fee. Whether they get to keep the flat fee or the label takes it would depend on the contract. With songwriting royalties, it depends. The label might still own it under a "any creative work made while under contract is legal property of the label"-type clause, or maybe not. Asian Junkie has a good post on it about how much different artists make, if you haven't checked that out yet, do so.

  9. I think is also worth mentioning the use of 'ghostwriters'. I am not sure if they are that popular in kpop, but they are for sure in all of mainstream western music.

    1. Yeah I could have gone there but I didn't want to spin things out too much and what I've got conveys the basics of what anyone needs to know. I also thought about writing about how people get paid on the technical side of things but then decided not to bother as it wasn't relevant to the central point.

  10. Isn't all of this kind of just common since??? I mean couldn't you just put in one word and have your name on the song writing credits? lol...

    1. Yes, and yes.

      I often feel that the things I write about are basic common sense... but go onto any k-pop forum and read people who are discussing this stuff, and you'll quickly realise that common sense isn't that common...

    2. I'll take your word for it. I went on a Kpop forum once and I never really looked back… lol

    3. Oh god I remember Beyonce' did that once. She changed Smack Into You to Smash Into You and received credit for it.

  11. CL composed? Did she rub the bottom row of her teeth against something and make a note?

    1. Who knows what the resonant frequencies of that dental work is.

  12. Yeah, everyone and their mommies are suddenly composers in K-pop nowadays.. I don't mind idols branching their stuffs into composing, it's their rights. Some of the songs they composed turned to be okay, some are very raw mess and show their incapability as a composer. The fangirls are annoying, though.. just because their oppas' names are credited in one of the crappy filler track in their album, they praise oppas are musical genius thus oppas are the great wall of China that other idols can't climb!!1!

    And OP, that jiminwantsjungkooksdick gif is precious.

    1. I asked Comekpop to gif that scene for me before I even knew where I was going to use it. I thought to myself "this has GOT to be useful in all sorts of contexts, I'll find a place soon enough".

  13. "just because their oppas' names are credited in one of the crappy filler track in their album, they praise oppas are musical genius thus oppas are the great wall of China that other idols can't climb!!1!"
    Ugh that shit defines YG stans like: "GD and CL are amazing artists, musical geniuses, rappers, fashionistas and make real music not like those SM robots!!111!11!!!" YG's marketing has seriously affected their logic and common sense.

  14. Before it was "omg Teddy sucks because he can't distribute lines equally, poor Dara. It's all Teddy's fault"
    Now that CL's name is in the credits "she's such an amazing leader for writing the songs. Oh, Dara still has the least lines and CL still overshadows the rest? Oh well that's just too bad, it's what makes the song sounds good."

    Ffs blackjacks.